Although there'll probably be some sort of a 'new manager bounce' at some point (poor Carrick and his team did appear to have 'lost the dressing-room'), and United clearly have enough talent to be some kind of a threat, I'm really not that optimistic about their chances of getting much higher than mid-table this season.
Dreadful recruitment over a number of years has left them without the personnel to implement an aggressive high-press - which is Pochettino's signature style, and has been a key part of what Ten Hag and Amorim and Carrick have all tried and failed to implement at the club over the last few seasons. They don't have a solid holding midfielder who can effectively police the wide open spaces in the middle of the park and give them some protection against the quick counter-attacks to which the high press will often expose them (Baleba seems to be constantly injured; and I'm not convinced that he's quite good enough anyway); they don't have enough forward players who will work hard enough to consistently and effectively operate that kind of pressing; they don't have an established centre-forward who can quickly and reliably convert the chances their high turnovers may create (I still have hopes for Sesko, but he too seems to be constantly injured; and, as I'd long suspected, Mbeumo and Cunha are looking like somewhat misguided purchases - not really gelling with the system, or with each other); and they don't have quick enough central defenders to maintain the high line required to compress play in the opposition half in order to make the press work.
It's been an ongoing clusterfuck for years now, and I can't see that changing very quickly. Pochettino might be a very, very good manager - but he's not a miracle-worker.
If I were a Manchester United fan, I think I'd fantasise about winding the clock back 2 years or so, to wipe away the repeated foot-shootings of the last couple of seasons - that might be the last point at which a decisive change for the better might have been made. If they'd had the courage to let Uncle Erik go straight after the FA Cup win, if they'd been able to hang on to Dan Ashworth, and if they'd been able to secure whoever he wanted as manager, rather than the disastrous Amorim,.... ah, what a wonderful world it could be.
But that moment is gone now; and there are such a lot of bad decisions since then that need to be slowly and painfully rectified. Without a major shake-up of the club's senior management (the INEOS intervention has proven to be comically inept; I doubt if fans will be happy until both Radcliffe and the Glazers sell up), and a massive and expensive squad rebuild next summer, I fear this once great club is doomed to another five years or so in the wilderness of mid-table mediocrity.
No comments:
Post a Comment
All viewpoints are welcome. But please have something useful and relevant to say, give clear reasons for your opinion, and try to use reasonably full and correct sentence structure. [Anything else will be deleted!]